Three Artists Withdraw From Berlin Biennale Over “Commodification” of Iraqi Suffering


3 Iraqi artists have withdrawn their participation from the Berlin Biennale after criticizing the inclusion of Jean-Jacques Lebel’s “Soluble Poison. Scenes from the American career (Baghdad)” (2013) — an set up such as a labyrinth plastered with digitally enlarged images of bodily and sexual torture infamously dedicated at Abu Ghraib. In a observe justifying their choice, the artists decried the “instrumentalization” in their “paintings and identities as Iraqi” by means of curators. 

Rijin Sahakian is a curator and artist who authored each the most recent announcement of the artists’ withdrawal of labor in addition to an open letter in Artforum in past due July outlining her grievances with the curation of Iraqi artists’ paintings. The twelfth version of the Biennale, which carries the theme “Nonetheless Provide!,” goals to interrogate “connections between colonialism, fascism, and imperialism, and suggest decolonial methods for the longer term.” Sahakian started advising the Biennale in past due 2021. She offered the paintings of Iraqi artists Sajjad Abbas and Layth Kareem to organizers, lent a portray by means of Iraqi artist Raed Mutar to the Biennale, and wrote catalogue texts on their artwork. Each and every in their contributions to the display wrestled with Iraq and Iraqis within the aftermath of the American invasion and career.

Given Sahakian’s intensive involvement main as much as the outlet of the Biennale, she used to be shocked to search out Lebel’s piece, that includes huge representations of Iraqi sufferers in an abject state of humiliation, in the similar room because the paintings of artists she had introduced into the fold. Lebel’s paintings used to be now not new; it used to be proven on the Palais de Tokyo in 2018.

“There used to be plentiful time to talk about the inclusion of the paintings in query previous to the exhibition opening in June,” Sahakian instructed Hyperallergic in an interview. “As an alternative, we have been faced with paintings and its collusion with our participation upon arrival on the museum.”

A cause caution for Lebel’s paintings used to be put in after the display opened. (courtesy Ali Yass)

Sahakian privately raised her considerations with organizers. However disappointed with the lackluster reaction she gained, she revealed an open letter co-signed by means of 15 artists — together with Abbas, Kareem, and Mutar — lambasting the Biennale for making “the verdict to commodify pictures of unlawfully imprisoned and brutalized Iraqi our bodies below career, exhibiting them with out the consent of the sufferers and with none enter from the Biennale’s taking part Iraqi artists, whose paintings used to be adjacently put in with out their wisdom.” Sahakian recommended the Biennale’s organizers to “rethink their inclusion of the paintings” and “acknowledge the rights of Iraqi artists to be consulted and to be heard.”

“The principle factor is that our our bodies don't seem to be that reasonable,” Ali Yass, an Iraqi artist who co-signed Sahakian’s letter, instructed Hyperallergic. Together with Lebel’s paintings, to him, “reproduces that oppression.”

One member of the Biennale’s creative workforce, Ana Teixeira Pinto, resigned from her put up in a while after the display opened. A spokesperson for the Berlin Biennale showed that Pinto stepped down because of “content-related variations revolving across the presentation of Jean-Jacques Lebel’s paintings.”

On Monday, August 15, the Berlin Biennale officially apologized to the Iraqi artists for the ache led to by means of striking their works adjoining to Lebel’s and for being sluggish of their relocation of them. Their apology used to be accompanied by means of a screed written basically by means of Kader Attia at the side of the remainder of the Biennale’s creative workforce justifying the inclusion of “Soluble Poison.” Attia argued that it used to be “vital to not indulge the impulse to show a blind eye to an overly contemporary imperialist crime—a criminal offense carried out below army career that used to be temporarily brushed below the rug with the purpose of prompting a swift forgetting.”

One of the most venues of the twelfth Berlin Beinalle, that includes Sajjad Abbas’ “I Can See You” (2013) (photograph by means of dotgain.information, courtesy the Berlin Biennale)

“If we don't display those photographs time and again, then we're protective the ones liable for those crimes, although it's more uncomplicated to be satisfied of the opposite within the dystopian convenience of the conservative fresh artwork international,” Attia wrote.

Sahakian, Abbas, Kareem, and Mutar have been swift of their reaction. By way of tomorrow, they'd united in taking flight their participation from the Biennale. “The curators make this declare by means of record their decolonial credentials whilst on the identical time lecturing us on perceive our personal historical past,” Sahakian wrote. “The curator’s creative apply and private circle of relatives historical past taking priority over the creative apply, lived enjoy, and circle of relatives histories of Iraqis speaks to the uneven energy this biennial is intent on generating in its discourse and in its curatorial negligence.”

The Berlin Biennale mentioned in a commentary that they revered its artists’ choice to withdraw whilst they “discovered about it with nice dismay.”

“We imagine in discussion and price the relationships now we have with all artists participating within the Berlin Biennale very a lot,” the Biennale’s commentary persevered. “We're nonetheless excited about running in the course of the controversy and can stay open to a discussion. Subsequently we want to invite all events concerned for a public discussion, as a result of we predict the problems at stakes are vital.”

“In an exhibition that prioritizes the show of wrongly imprisoned Iraqis photographed within the act of being sexually and bodily tortured, no, we don't in finding sincerity or transparency on this paternalistic reaction,” Sahakian concluded.